Firm Caddy
From the fieldPaid SearchNovember 12, 20266 min read

Geo Targeting Google Ads Across the Valley: Stop Paying for Clicks You Can't Sign

Most Phoenix injury firms lose ad budget on geography before a single bad keyword fires. The usual culprits are Google’s default "presence or interest" setting, one big radius drawn around the office, and no excluded areas. Fixing those three is the cheapest win in most accounts. Then you can target the Valley the way crashes and cases actually happen: by city, by freeway corridor and by hour.

TL;DR

  • Switch every campaign to "Presence: people in or regularly in your targeted locations."
  • Target the cities you can serve and sign, not a 30 mile circle.
  • Exclude the places you’ll never take a case from.
  • Use the location report and your own call data to move bids by city and hour.

The setting that wastes the most money

In each campaign, open Settings, then Locations, then Location options. If it says "Presence or interest," your ads are showing to people who are merely interested in Phoenix. That includes someone in Chicago reading about a crash on the I-10. Switch it to "Presence: people in or regularly in your targeted locations." Do the same for exclusions so you only exclude people actually located there.

Draw the map around cases, not your office

A radius around a downtown office puts budget into places you don’t want and misses places you do. Build targeting from your signed cases instead:

  1. Export the addresses of your last 50 to 100 signed clients from case management.
  2. Count them by city and ZIP code.
  3. Target the cities that produced cases, plus their neighbors.
  4. Exclude everything you can’t or won’t serve: Tucson if you don’t practice there, tribal lands where your firm doesn’t handle claims, and anywhere a two hour drive kills the case economics.

Think in corridors

Injury searches often happen near the crash, the hospital or the body shop, not at home. The Valley’s freeways concentrate that activity: the I-10 through Tempe and downtown, the I-17 north and south, the Loop 101 and Loop 202 rings, the US 60 through the East Valley and the Loop 303 in the far West Valley. ADOT’s 2024 numbers show where volume clusters. Phoenix logged 37,472 crashes, Mesa 8,022 and Tempe 6,637, more than Chandler or Scottsdale despite Tempe’s smaller population.

Layer city targeting over those corridors and give the busiest cities their own ad groups and landing pages.

Schedule by hour, but use your own data

ADOT’s 2024 statewide data:

MeasurePeak
Hour for all crashes3 to 4 PM
Day for all crashesFriday
Hour for fatal crashes6 to 7 PM
Hour for alcohol related crashes2 to 3 AM
Share of fatal crashes on weekends39.75%

Crash time isn’t search time. People often search after the ER visit or the next morning. Use the crash pattern to make sure ads and intake are live when it matters, then let your own call data set bid adjustments. If calls between 9 PM and midnight go to voicemail, fix intake before you raise night bids.

Read the location report monthly

In Google Ads, open the Locations view and report on matched locations, not just targeted ones. Sort by cost. Any city with real spend and no conversions over 60 days is a candidate to cut. Then check those conversions against signed cases in your CRM. A city that produces calls but never signs isn’t converting.

Bid adjustments that make sense

Once you have about 30 days of conversion data, raise bids 15 to 30 percent in the cities with the lowest cost per signed case and lower them in cities that cost double your average. Ignore cities with too few conversions to read. If you’re running a Smart Bidding strategy that ignores location adjustments, split campaigns by city tier instead.

FAQ

What location setting should a Phoenix law firm use in Google Ads? "Presence: people in or regularly in your targeted locations" for nearly every injury campaign.

Should I use a radius or city targeting in Phoenix? City and ZIP targeting built from your signed cases usually beats a radius around the office.

What hours should PI ads run? Whenever intake can answer live. Crash peaks run in the afternoon and evening, but your own call data should set the bids.

Get your map checked

Book 30 minutes at firmcaddy.com. We’ll pull your location report and show you where the budget is leaking.

Geography is one piece of a Valley strategy. The Phoenix market write-up covers the rest, and a fixed scope account review will tell you what your current build is leaking before you rebuild it.

Sources: ADOT 2024 Crash Facts

Keep reading

Book a call.
Firm Caddy, Phoenix, Arizona Work Blog About