PPC Agency vs In House: Who Should Run a Law Firm's Google Ads?
Agency or in house matters less than most firms think. What matters is whether someone strong in PPC is on your side of the table, checking the work. Most of the agency proposals I see for law firms are a flat monthly fee, and that fee is the same whether your account gets better or worse. Hire an agency with nobody at the firm who can read the account, and the only review of their work is the report they wrote about themselves.
TL;DR
- The real question is who checks the work, not who does it.
- Most agency fees I see are flat, which pays the same whether you sign more cases or fewer.
- A full time PPC specialist has a median salary of $78,760, about $6,563 a month before benefits.
- If you hire an agency, put someone who knows Google Ads over it, in house or fractional.
- Keep the ad account and the call tracking in your firm’s name either way.
What in house really costs
The person you’d hire to run Google Ads falls under what the Bureau of Labor Statistics calls market research analysts and marketing specialists. The median pay there was $78,760 in May 2025. That’s the salary line. Benefits, payroll tax, call tracking software and the months it takes to hire and ramp someone all sit on top.
There’s also a single point of failure. When your one PPC person leaves, the reasons the account is built the way it is leave with them, and the next hire usually starts by tearing it down.
What an agency really costs
Most of the agency proposals I see for law firms are a flat monthly fee. Some charge a percentage of ad spend instead, and AgencyAnalytics’ 2025 pricing guide puts that at 10 to 20 percent. On a percentage deal, the fee passes a specialist’s median salary once you’re spending somewhere between about $33,000 and $66,000 a month on ads.
The fee isn’t really the problem though. On a flat fee, your account is one of many and it gets about the attention the fee pays for. The agency gets paid the same if your cost per signed case drops by half or doubles. That’s not bad people. That’s just how the model works, and it’s why the agency can’t be the only one looking at the account.
You need someone strong in it either way
Whichever way you go, somebody on your side has to actually know Google Ads. Not someone who reads the summary slide. Someone who can open the account and spot broad match terms piling up, a negative keyword list nobody’s touched since launch, or calls that never got tracked.
That person can be on payroll. It can be a fractional marketing lead who goes through the account every month. It just can’t be nobody, because then the report is the review, and the report is written by the people being reviewed.
Where each one breaks
In house breaks when nobody checks the work. One person running the account with no peer review can drift for months, and the person reporting the results is the person who’d get blamed for them.
An agency breaks when the reporting stops at cost per lead, when the agency owns the ad account, or when your intake gets treated as somebody else’s problem. Any one of those means you’re paying for activity you can’t connect to cases. Five red flags in agency reporting goes into more detail.
The setup that works
Have the ads run by someone who answers to cost per signed case, in an account you own, with someone strong in PPC checking it. That can be an agency with a fractional lead over it. Or it can be what we do: we build and run the campaigns, the account stays in your name, and every report ends with what a signed case cost by campaign. That’s the way we run engagements from the first week. For how we structure campaigns in the Valley, Google Ads for Phoenix injury firms walks through it.
FAQ
Is it cheaper to run Google Ads in house? Usually not at smaller budgets. A specialist’s median salary is $78,760, about $6,563 a month before benefits and tools. Compare that to the agency’s fee. On a percentage deal at 10 to 20 percent of spend, the agency costs more once spend passes somewhere between about $33,000 and $66,000 a month.
Do we still need someone in house if we hire a PPC agency? You need someone who knows Google Ads well enough to challenge the agency. That can be an employee or a fractional marketing lead. Without one, the agency is grading its own work.
What should we ask a PPC agency before hiring them? Whose name the ad account is in, what the fee is and whether it changes with spend, and whether they’ll report cost per signed case by campaign. If they can’t answer the last one, they’re reporting on activity.
Want a second opinion on your account?
Give me read access and I’ll tell you what I’d keep, what I’d cut, and whether you need an agency at all. Call me at 509-440-2131 or book 30 minutes. How our Google Ads management works is laid out on one page.
Aiden DeVere runs Firm Caddy, a Phoenix based fractional marketing team for law firms. Before Firm Caddy, he spent four years as the sole marketing operator at a multi state injury firm.
Sources: BLS, Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists, AgencyAnalytics, PPC pricing guide (2025)